When Ruler Fails People Protect Public Interest
Nidhu Bhushan Das
"The Myth and Aura Will Pass Away" is the title of my blog post published here seven years from now on 4 February 2012. I wrote: "The Mamata myth appears to be waning rapidly after Ms Banerjee has become the Chief Minister of West Bengal. The Chief Minister tends more to play to the gallery than to be serious about steering the state clear of the mess she inherited from the left rule of about 35 years. She deserves credit for the ouster of the Left Front from power. It was she who pulled down the left edifice which once was thought to be impregnable. Her sustained movement against what was seen as left misrule earned her the credibility which ultimately catapulted her to power in the state. Once in power, she is in a hurry to project herself as the Santa Claus to the people, and heaps promise upon promise to keep the people in good humour.Even she squanders money in the form of donations to the clubs of the state and her government organizes gala festivals while roads and highways remain degraded."
In the seven years her policies, political moves and manoeuvres have led to many developments which appear to be the cause of her undoing,nay hubris is the cause.
Her idioms suggest she fails to distinguish between democracy and autocracy, between the power of the people and that of an individual.When the will and the rights of the people are sought to be subordinated to the will and caprices of the individual on whom the people repose their trust for a fixed period,people feel being betrayed and teach the individual a lesson.The hubris of the individual activates the autocrat in him/her and accelerate the undoing of the ruler.
The West Bengal Chief Minister has ,of late,developed an allergy towards the slogan "Joy Shri Ram". Whenever she hears the slogan, she loses her cool, disembark from her car to chase away the sloganeers who appear to be persistent.The problem is personal and once it is found in someone, fun loving people may find it an opportunity to exploit the supersensitivity of the person just for fun.The Hindustan Times reported on 31 May: "West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee lost her temper on Thursday when protesters shouted ‘Jai Shri Ram” and “Jai Modi” slogans while she was on her way to a sit-in venue.
She got out of her car twice when she heard the slogans. Banerjee shouted back at the crowd and asked policemen to identify the slogan shouters and conduct an house-to-house search."
This reaction of the Chief Minister (twice in a month) is the talking point and issue of satiric comments at street corners,markets and other public places.It appears the proactive Chief Minister has turned reactive to her perils.
This change in her suggests she has the dearth of ideas to face the political development thrown up by the Lok Sabha polls in which BJP decimated her party TMC.The need of the hour is statesmanship,not being temperamental.Democracy demands reasonable space for debate and discussion,respect for the views and opinions of the opposition.Stifling the opposition does not augur well for democracy.We may buy support or force opposition into submission but the vox populi cannot be silenced,public conscience cannot be bought.Rulers who tried so brought about their own doom across the globe.After all, "the voice of the people is the voice of God."(Vox Populi, Vox Dei).Voice of the ruler is subordinate to the voice of the people.When the ruler fails to be just,people act wisely to protect public interest.
